Home > Uncategorized > Greta Callahan: Walk in My Shoes Before You Criticize

Greta Callahan: Walk in My Shoes Before You Criticize

November 10, 2014

This Kindergarten teacher’s article illustrates that one size does NOT fit all when it comes to evaluation and poverty DOES matter… a LOT more than “bad teachers”.

Diane Ravitch's blog

Greta Callahan’s article about teaching kindergarten in Minneapolis went viral. She wrote her article in response to one that appeared in the same paper asserting the “worst teachers are in the poorest schools.” She teaches in one of the poorest schools, and she tells her story.

To those who parrot the false claim that low test scores are caused by “bad teachers,” she offers a counter-narrative. She explains the burdens suffered by her students and the stress of being evaluated by a rubric that makes no sense.

Let’s start with what it means to be a “good teacher.” As the article says: “The district uses three different tools to evaluate teachers: classroom observations, a student survey and student achievement data.” Let’s put that into the perspective of a Bethune kindergarten teacher.

• Classroom observations: We have four per year. The teacher receives points based on standardized criteria; the feedback is…

View original post 787 more words

Categories: Uncategorized
%d bloggers like this: