Home > Uncategorized > Minnesota: Why Campbell Brown’s Lawsuit Against Tenure was Thrown Out

Minnesota: Why Campbell Brown’s Lawsuit Against Tenure was Thrown Out

November 6, 2016

A big “OOPS” in Minnesota! Thanks Campbell Brown for letting us learn that “Minnesota Charter schools, which do not have tenure, are disproportionally represented among Minnesota’s lowest performing schools.”

Diane Ravitch's blog

Earlier today, I posted Mercedes Schneider’s report about Campbell Brown’s failed lawsuit in Minnesota, where she was trying to get another Vergara-style decision to abolish teacher tenure.

I noted that the judge who tossed the lawsuit said that Brown and her “Partnership for Educational Justice” failed to show a connection between low test scores.

But the state’s own filing against the lawsuit added another important point, which I overlooked. Charter schools are disproportionately represented among the state’s lowest scoring schools, and their teachers do not have tenure. That argument blew a huge hole in the claim of Brown and her PEJ that tenure “causes” low test scores.

Here is the quote that Mercedes drew from the state’s document:

“Plaintiffs Lack Standing. The State Defendants demonstrated in their initial memorandum that Plaintiffs lacked standing because their First Amended Complaint failed to identify a concrete, particularized, and actual or imminent “injury-in-fact,” fairly…

View original post 111 more words

Categories: Uncategorized
%d bloggers like this: