Home > Uncategorized > State Mandated Rating Systems Reinforce Commodification… Multiple Metrics Determined by Local Boards the Best Accountability

State Mandated Rating Systems Reinforce Commodification… Multiple Metrics Determined by Local Boards the Best Accountability

November 3, 2018

Diane Ravitch’s posted blogger Laura Chapman’s critique of Ohio’s rating system for schools that, in response to ESSA mandates, now incorporates “multiple measures”. But the results of changing to multiple measures made no difference in terms of what the report cards actually measure: family income and education.

To my surprise, neither Diane Ravitch nor Laura Chapman nor any of the commenters noted the interest flaw of rating systems: the fact that they reinforce the commodification of public schools. Ratings were introduced by “reformers” based on the premise that parents can shop for schools the way they shop for cars or groceries. Until affluent school districts with space in their classrooms open their doors to children raised in poverty in neighboring districts these ratings should be ignored.

BTW, one of the most bogus “selling points” of ESSA was the notion that STATES would be in complete control of the mandated rating system, a system that would ultimately need to be approved by the USDOE. If you think any state will abandon standardized testing as the primary metric there is a bridge I can sell you…. And worse yet, in the case of Ohio, one of the”multiple measures” is the introduction of a value added metric… despite the fact that VAM has been repeatedly discredited.

Advertisements
%d bloggers like this: